A Specialized Personal Injury & Mass Tort Trial Firm. Getting Extraordinary Results for Ordinary People: Creating the Right Team to Take on Select Cases that Excite Attorneys, Right Wrongs and... Optimizing Your Law Firm’s Financial Health in 2019: Four Areas to Focus Your Spring Cleaning: Fingerprints are unique. No two snowflakes are alike. And each law firm has its own... How to Find and Keep Talent in a Highly Competitive Market: One of the biggest problems companies face, in particular middle market companies, is a... Lessons Learned from Navy SEALs: I will admit it up front—I am in awe of Navy SEALs. My brother-in-law was a career... To Speak Like the Best, You Need to Prep Like the Best: I recently went to the Legal Marketing Association’s (LMA) educational program,... Overconfidence and Law Firm Decline: “Every institution is vulnerable, no matter how great. No matter how much you have... Making a Move with a Purpose: Three to five years into an associate’s legal career is the prime time for associates... Snap! And You Miss It: Snapchat and other photo-sharing apps have redefined how users and employees share... Nobody Wants a Debbie Downer During Initial Consultations: Initial consultations are an important part of most law firms. Potential clients meet... Community News – April 2019: Fifteen Wilson Turner Kosmo attorneys have been selected for inclusion on the San Diego...
Executive Presentations-468x60-1

Up To The Challenge

Complexities and Complications Inherent in Medical Malpractice Cases Are No Match for Chihak & Martel Partner Amy Rose Martel

“My mom worked as a paralegal for a plaintiff’s medical malpractice lawyer in Orange County, when I was growing up. She would tell me about the cases that they were working on and I was always fascinated. What made the greatest impression on me was how hard they fought for their clients and how their efforts could make a huge impact on their clients’ lives. I knew in the 1st grade that I wanted to be a lawyer. Of course, what I did not understand when I was growing up, were the challenges that MICRA presents,” says Amy Rose Martel, who made Partner at Chihak & Martel in early 2016.
After growing up in Norco, CA, and earning her Bachelor’s Degree from the University of Washington, Martel moved to America’s Finest City in 2001 to attend the University of San Diego School of Law where she was a member of the Mock Trial team, and chair of the Pro Bono Legal Society. After graduation, Martel accepted a position with the defense firm she had clerked for while in law school. “I loved my job at Lincoln, Gustafson, & Cercos and could not have asked for a better group of people to work with. However, I knew that defending insurance companies was not my calling.
I have been extremely fortunate throughout my life, and have been given so many amazing opportunities. I recognize that others are not as fortunate as I have been, and it is why I feel the need to help others and to give back to my community,” she explains.

Amy Rose Martel

Competitive Spirit
Fortunately, Martel is incredibly competitive by nature. An avid runner, she was the team captain of the cross country and track teams in college, she has completed marathons, half iron-man triathlons and she recently took up mountain biking. So, when a chance encounter as an associate pitted her against Cynthia Chihak, one of San Diego’s most respected and revered plaintiff’s medical malpractice attorneys, Martel did what she has always done. She geared up to compete.
“In 2007 I was working on a large auto wrongful death case and Cynthia was the opposing counsel. She is straight up intimidating in deposition. I was immediately impressed with her, and worked ten times harder on that case, because I knew that unless I wanted to get crushed, I needed to be on my A game,” Martel recalls.
Continuing she says, “While working on that case, I remember saying to my husband, as we drove past her office, “I am going to work for Cynthia Chihak someday.” I knew I wanted to work for her because she exemplifies everything I love about being a trial lawyer: she is hard working, smart, prepared and she is not afraid to fight for her clients. A year later we settled the case, and she offered me a job,” Martel says. Thus, in 2008, Martel joined Chihak’s established firm, and began cutting her teeth in the field of medical malpractice.
Suffice it to say, the opportunity to finally fight for the victims of medical malpractice was incredibly rewarding, eyeopening and emotional for Martel, who had long dreamed of helping others through catastrophic injuries. She recalls, “During my first year working with Cynthia, we arbitrated a failure to diagnose case. Unfortunately, by the time our client’s cancer was diagnosed it was terminal. We won the arbitration and when we got the award of $2.3 million, we called him. I’ll never forget what he said as he cried and thanked us. He said “now I can die peacefully because I know my kids will be taken care of.” He did pass away a few days later. I had always known I wanted to be a plaintiff’s lawyer but his words validated every step I took to get here.”
Regarding the challenges she now relishes, Martel comments, “Medical malpractice is very much a David & Goliath area of law. It’s a tough practice area. The cap on general damages and attorneys’ fees discourages a lot of people. Medical insurers fight hard and put a lot of resources into not paying victims. You’re also always opposing some of the best defense attorneys out there. There is no such thing as an easy medical malpractice case.”
Although the odds are stacked against plaintiffs, Martel says that the firm welcomes the fight. “Cynthia and I are both very competitive and neither one of us are afraid to put in the hard work that it takes to succeed. There is no substitute for working hard and being good at your craft.” Plus, she explains, although the partners are both competitive, they aren’t competitive with each other. Instead, when it comes to fighting for a client, the entire team works on the case, and all attorneys in the firm know exactly where the case stands. “We maintain a small caseload which allows us to give each case the attention it deserves,” she says. “We are fortunate to have big firm resources, and we refuse to cut corners, but we also don’t waste 8 hours in a deposition, when it can be handled in 2 hours.” Although Martel and Chihak are always representing the “underdog” in medical malpractice, or in select premises liability, product defect and personal injury cases, their reputation for civility in working with opposing counsel is well established. “Thanks to Cynthia’s years of dedication and success, our firm has an excellent reputation. I believe people know that we are honest, aggressive and not afraid to stand up for our clients. We are trial lawyers, not settlement lawyers. Every case we take, we prepare it like we will try it. We will not sell our clients short to avoid trial,” she says.
In spite of their reputation for going to trial, Martel explains that the firm has not only managed to build civil relationships with the defense attorneys they are opposing, but that she has become friends with many of the medical malpractice defense lawyers she routinely challenge. “We do see the same attorneys a lot, and we believe in civility. Of course, there are times when things become contentious, but overall we have excellent relationships with attorneys we oppose. In fact, when I made Partner earlier this year, several defense lawyers came to our party,” she says.

Amy Rose Martel

Curious Mind
Much of Martel’s passion for plaintiff’s work lies in the fact that there is frankly never a dull moment. In other words, the fact that she continues to be challenged to learn something new on a daily basis is exhilarating.
“Medical malpractice is a tough field; you must be prepared to go toe-to-toe with a doctor in their field of expertise, which is not easy for someone with no medical background. But I would rather work until midnight than show up unprepared,” she says. “If I am going to be taking the deposition of a surgeon, I need to understand the medicine, the indications for the surgery, the surgical procedure itself and the potential complications, and be able to speak intelligently about it. I spend a lot of time doing medical research and I enjoy it. We also have terrific medical experts we have built relationships with, who we can call and ask questions about a particular procedure or aspect of the case,” Martel explains.
In fact, the reputation of Chihak and Martel is so favorable, that Martel says that many of the firm’s cases are referred by physicians. “We have sued a doctor, and then had him refer us a case, and serve as the medical expert,” she says. Likewise, the firm also receives plenty of referrals from colleagues in other practice areas. “In some regards we are lucky, because there are not a lot of attorneys who do medical malpractice cases. We have earned the referrals, and the referrals that come to us are generally very good cases,” Martel says. In fact, referrals to Chihak & Martel from other attorneys, judges and doctors account for roughly 80% of the firm’s business.

Amy Rose Martel

Compassionate Leader
As a trial lawyer and a mother to two young sons, Martel is admittedly aggressive and competitive, but says her role as a mother has taught her a great deal about patience and empathy when it comes to helping her clients to cope with their injuries or loss. “Clients can contact me anytime. I am here to fight, but I am also here to listen to them and offer a compassionate ear,” she says. “It is important for me to not only be a great trial lawyer, but to have compassion.”
“I am beyond lucky that my husband is a stay-at-home dad, which allows me the time and opportunity to be a trial lawyer, which often requires long hours and time away from home. Being a trial lawyer is my dream job. But being a mom to Waylon and Charlie is what defines me, challenges me, and inspires me,” she says. “Having two little boys means we are always on the go, I do not have any down time. It is important for me to not only be a good lawyer but to be a good mom. But it is hard to do both, sometimes I have to miss the kids’ events and sometimes I have to miss work-related events. There is always “mom” guilt, but I do my best to be efficient, and present with whatever I am doing.”
As such, cases involving children strike a chord with her, while providing her with an opportunity to give back. By way of example, Martel recalls a case from several years ago in which the firm had an 8-year-old client, who had a tumor on her neck which was misdiagnosed. “I remember reading her discovery responses, which she wrote herself. In describing how this tumor impacted her life, she wrote that she just wanted to feel normal, and that she was sad she would never have a boyfriend and never get married. She wrote that she had never been around anyone who looked like her.”
“Reading this in her own handwritten words brought me to tears. I wanted to do something for this little girl, other than just resolve her case. As it happened, my uncle had started a camp for seriously ill children in Carnation, Washington, in honor of my cousin who died from cancer. Today Camp Korey is part of Paul Newman’s SeriousFun Network of camps which help children who are ill to experience the simple joy of camp, the thrill of just being a kid, free of charge. I was able to get her a spot in the camp. For 7 days, she laughed, danced and most importantly, she felt like a normal kid. I got a picture of her from Camp Korey dressed up in a lion’s costume for a play she was in, and her smile was worth more than any verdict,” Martel says.
In addition to supporting children’s causes, Martel is dedicated to helping those less fortunate in San Diego, through her role on the Board of Directors of Traveler’s Aid Society, a position she has held for more than a decade. “Traveler’s Aid is a private, nonprofit agency that provides crisis and short-term assistance for food, shelter, and transportation, for San Diegans in need. Our mobile mom’s program, for example, provides transportation to low-income pregnant women so that they can get to their pre- and post-natal appointments. We also provide rides to veterans and seniors to help them get to doctor’s appointments. Transportation is an often forgotten aspect of social services and we fill that gap,” Martel says.
As far as the future is concerned for Martel, her game plan is firmly in place.In addition to continuing to provide unparalleled advocacy for clients who have been harmed through no fault of their own, or through her commitment to giving back to the legal community, and the San Diego community at large, Martel is very clear about what she hopes to accomplish in the future. “My mom always inspired me to work hard.
She set the bar for having strong morals and integrity. Cynthia shaped my career into what it is today. I will be forever humbled that she chose to put my name next to hers. By taking on additional leadership roles in the legal field, such as serving as the Secretary of Consumer Attorneys of San Diego in 2017, I want to pay this forward by trying to be an example to younger women who want to be trial lawyers.”



  • University of San Diego School of Law, San Diego, California – 2003
  • Honors: Chair, The Pro Bono Legal Society
  • Honors: Member, Mock Trial Team
  • University of Washington – 1999
  • Honors: Member, The Cross Country and Track Teams


  • California State Bar, Member
  • Consumer Attorneys of San Diego, Member
  • Consumer Attorneys of San Diego, Board of Directors, 2014–Present
  • San Diego County Bar Association, Member
  • Nevada State Bar Association, Member
  • Traveler's Aid Society, Board of Directors, 2003–Present
  • American Inns of Court, J. Clifford Wallace, Barrister
  • Named one of San Diego's Top Attorneys by Super Lawyer Magazine, 2015–Present
  • San Diego Business Journal Best of the Bar, 2015–Present

Amy Rose Martel
Chihak & Martel
12555 High Bluff Drive, Suite 150

Jennifer Hadley

Jennifer Hadley is a Staff Writer for Attorney Journal

More Posts

Digg This
Reddit This
Stumble Now!
Buzz This
Vote on DZone
Share on Facebook
Bookmark this on Delicious
Kick It on DotNetKicks.com
Shout it
Share on LinkedIn
Bookmark this on Technorati
Post on Twitter
Google Buzz (aka. Google Reader)
www.pdf24.org    Send article as PDF   

Filed Under: Business ManagementFeatured Stories

About the Author: Jennifer Hadley is a Staff Writer for Attorney Journal

RSSComments (0)

Trackback URL

Leave a Reply

  • Polls